The Voluntary Carbon Credit Scandal - tell your friends and your grandparents!


In my view the sale of voluntary carbon credits is the biggest mis-selling scandal currently going on in today's retail investment markets, but ironically the Financial Services Authority do not consider it within their remit or power to do anything about it...

Immoral Salesmen

I have been consulted by a gentlemen who was helped by the carbon credit salesman to put all of his share portfolio onto a platform in order to sell it to purchase carbon credits. As a result this person lost over £300,000 and over 80% of his investment wealth. The gentleman in question I would deem as susceptible and vulnerable and in need of protection. Indeed this particular gentlemen wrote to the FSA asking for help in the middle of this process and bought further carbon credits after communication with them, because the carbon credit salesman said it would 'diversify' his risk!! There are people out there selling these as investments and saying that they will double your money, when in fact the credits are massively overpriced for what they are (even when you accept that you will never be able to sell them on to anybody else) and I suspect that well over half of the money that is raised is going into the pockets of the salesmen themselves. So in the case of my gentleman the salesman may well have earned £150k of commission.

Carbon Credits are not investments

The facts are that voluntary carbon credits are not investments. There is no secondary market for them so you cannot sell them in the future. Voluntary carbon credits are designed to help companies offset their carbon emissions and companies do not buy these from retail investors. We all have a duty to tell everyone we know about this, especially our grandparents, because people are still losing huge sums of money from unscrupulous and immoral salesmen.

What is regulation for?

As a profession Independent Financial Advisers are scrutinised and monitored to the nth degree while carbon credit salesman are doing this. If you uncover these sort of practices first hand it is tear jerking stuff and is what regulation should be designed to stop. It is mind boggling that this seems to be under the legislative radar.

We all have a responsibility to shout about this from the treetops

Tags:

Comments (0)

Please login or register to comment.

Get investment advice

Speak to a specialist adviser for help in choosing the right green or ethical investment.



Request contact

or call 020 7812 1460

Holden & Partners



Worldwise Investor on your smart phone: find out more

Mark Hoskinall articles

Mark Hoskin is a Partner at Holden & Partners. Holden & Partners are Chartered Financial Planners who provide financial advice to high net worth clients, the majority of whom have a significant interest in ethical or environmental issues.

Mark Hoskin graduated with a History degree from Keble College, Oxford and went on to become a Chartered Accountant with Price Waterhouse. He cofounded Holden & Partners in 2003 and is a Certified Financial Planner and Chartered Financial Planner. Holden & Partners set up Worldwise Investor to help both advisers and investors understand quickly and easily how they can benefit from ethical and environmental investment in the UK market.


Blogs keyword search


Blogs by category

Blogs by month

Blogs by author

RSS  Latest blogs comments 24 comments

How Capital Markets and the West laugh in the face of carbon emissions - while looking holier than thou!

Thanks for that insight Mark. It is depressing to be reminded that hypocrisy is so rife in this...

Patrick Smyth | 1 month, 3 weeks ago | read more

Sustainability should be part of a debate on how we explain Investment Risk

Mark this is a major challenge for everybody connected to promoting SRI. UKSIF have just been...

Richard Essex | 2 months ago | read more

Al Gore's Most Important Talk Ever

Good point well made.

We need more high profile people like Al Gore to be making...

Richard Essex | 2 months, 3 weeks ago | read more

The Voluntary Carbon Credit scam goes on

I have just come across a site:

Mark Hoskin | 2 months, 4 weeks ago | read more

The Voluntary Carbon Credit scam goes on

And here is the response I received to reporting the above matter to the SFO via email. It appears...

Mark Hoskin | 3 months ago | read more

» all blogs discussion




The value of ethical and green investments can go down in value as well as up, so you could get back less than you invest. It is therefore important that you understand the risks of investing. Our aim is to provide you with the best information we can to help you make decisions about ethical and green investments. It is not to advise you on the suitability of an investment to your personal circumstances. Nothing written on the site should be considered personal advice, nor do Holden & Partners accept liability for any inaccurate information on the site. If you are unsure about the suitability of an ethical and green investment please contact Holden & Partners or your financial adviser.

design/build by lexicon

© Worldwise Investor c/o Holden & Partners, The Piano Works, 117 Farringdon Road, London, EC1R 3BX 020 7812 1460 info@worldwiseinvestor.com
Worldwise Investor and Holden & Partners are trading names of Peter.R.T.Holden & Partners LLP regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (446291).