Cameron fails to convince business and environmental groups with green energy speech


Last week, Prime Minister David Cameron addressed the third Clean Energy Ministerial (CEM3) in London, a meeting of energy ministers from more than 20 countries.

His speech was his first significant one on the environment since he came into office, and was an attempt to confirm his commitment to renewable energy. But environmental campaigners and green energy investors had hoped for a more firm policy speech that would encourage investment in an area that has been rocked by uncertainty and government divisions.

Cameron: Renewable energy ‘vital to our future’

Prime Minister David CameronAs reported by Worldwise Investor last week, Cameron had been under fire recently from his own backbenchers, who openly opposed the development and subsidising of green technologies, particularly wind power. At a time when the oil and gas industry received a £3bn tax break in the Chancellor’s recent budget, and when green energy subsidies were being slashed, the government’s mixed messages were jeopardising green investment.

At CEM3, Cameron told delegates he ‘passionately believed’ that the growth of renewable energy is ‘vital to our future.’

With global energy demand forecast to increase by 40 percent in the next 20 years, Cameron said, ‘we urgently need a more diverse, cleaner mix of energy sources that will give us energy security without causing irreparable damage to the planet.’ He said that nuclear energy, cleaner coal, oil and gas, and carbon capture and storage will all have an important role to play alongside renewable energy.

He said he had made good on his promise to be the ‘greenest government ever,’ saying the UK is ‘one of the best places for green energy, for green electricity, for green investment and crucially for green jobs anywhere in the world.’ He cited examples such as payments to businesses that generate their own renewable electricity, the first green investment bank, his carbon capture and storage programme, and the largest offshore wind market in the world, as proof of his achievement, as well as the fact that 10 percent of our energy needs were met by renewables in 2011.

We need cheaper energy, says Cameron

Whilst Cameron claimed the UK’s efforts in recent years to develop and encourage investment had made the renewable energy market here possible, he said the UK and other countries now faced a new challenge: making it affordable.

‘At a time when higher gas prices are leaving families and businesses struggling with their energy bills…and when we are fighting to get to grips with our debts, we don't just need greener energy – we need cheaper energy too,’ Cameron told delegates. ‘Today renewable energy is still relatively expensive.’

His remarks were criticised by business groups and environmental organisations from the Climate Group to WWF-UK, who said he continued to portray renewable energy as a burden and unaffordable – a lack of faith which will only sap confidence from investors. In addition, his speech had originally been planned as a keynote policy speech, but instead was reduced to seven minutes of introductory remarks, which fuelled criticism from Labour.

New investments and industry partnership for North Sea

North Sea wind farmCameron said in his remarks that ‘one of the biggest opportunities’ for renewable energy investment lies in the North Sea. He praised the way the private sector and government worked together to help give Britain a competitive advantage in North Sea oil and gas from the 1960’s. And so he called on ‘that same partnership between government and business’ to bring about another revolution in the North Sea by investing in off-shore wind power and carbon capture and storage. To that end, Cameron announced a new industry partnership comprising 20 companies, committing to ‘the long term vision of a second renewable energy revolution in the North Sea.’ The partnership will look into ways to maximise the use of wind energy from the North Sea and research ways to bring down its cost. 

However, Cameron will have to realise this vision without the help of Shell, who announced it would not invest in off-shore wind farms in the North Sea, saying the numbers ‘didn’t add up.’

Along with the North Sea partnership, other new clean energy investments were announced at the summit. A £300 million biomass project by Helius Energy at the Port of Bristol was also announced, while E.ON said it was awarding a major contract for the installation of cables for its Humber Gateway offshore wind farm to British company Balfour Beatty. Meanwhile Eneco and EDF are set to form a joint venture to develop the Navitus Bay offshore wind farm to the west of the Isle of Wight.

Green agenda

With the government promising to meet 20% of its energy demand through clean sources and with aggressive targets to cut carbon emissions, many business and environmental groups may feel that David Cameron still needs to convince investors of his commitment to the green agenda that he promised in his election campaign.

Fund context:

Sarasin New Power Fund invests primarily in companies that have an innovative approach to the use of energy and whose commitment to sustainability also takes into consideration environmental and social aspects. Special attention is paid to companies active in renewable energies such as wind, water, biofuels, solar and geothermal power. 

Pictet Clean Energy Fund invests in carbon free energy such as wind, low carbon energy such as natural gas, and energy efficiency such as efficient lighting.

Related funds:

Pictet Clean Energy
Sarasin New Power

Useful links:

David Cameron’s remarks

Clean Energy Ministerial website

Guardian article on reaction to David Cameron’s speech

Tags: UK | Clean Energy |

Comments (1)

  1. Shell believe that it does not ad up, i wonder if they would say the same after considering the long term effects of oil peak , climate change etc. i rather have expensive wind farms then have no energy at all.

    By dawid eugeniusz ptak on May 10, 2012 at 08:15 PM

Please login or register to comment.

Get investment advice

Speak to a specialist adviser for help in choosing the right green or ethical investment.



Request contact

or call 020 7812 1460

Holden & Partners



Worldwise Investor on your smart phone: find out more

Carol Wongall articles

Carol Wong is a freelance writer for Worldwise Investor.


News keyword search


News by category

News by month

News by author

RSS  Latest news comments 24 comments

Unregulated Collective Investment schemes (UCIS) - Why use them and what do you need to know?

And so now the FSA are looking to ban UCIS for retail investors. See

Mark Hoskin | 8 months, 3 weeks ago | read more

The story of 'Closed' funds on Worldwise Investor

The soft closure of the two First State Funds does not mean they are completely closed to new...

Susan Seymour | 9 months, 4 weeks ago | read more

Is Environmental Investing Dead in the UK Equity Income Market?

The Multi-Asset approach seems to be a sensibel approach.

There looks to be quite a...

Richard Essex | 9 months, 4 weeks ago | read more

Is Environmental Investing Dead in the UK Equity Income Market?

Our view is that multi-asset investing is a very different discipline to long-only equity (which is...

William Buckhurst | 10 months ago | read more

Is Environmental Investing Dead in the UK Equity Income Market?

Has the same sort of definition slipping also happened to Jupiter Ecology? I hope not.

Susan Seymour | 10 months ago | read more

» all news discussion




The value of ethical and green investments can go down in value as well as up, so you could get back less than you invest. It is therefore important that you understand the risks of investing. Our aim is to provide you with the best information we can to help you make decisions about ethical and green investments. It is not to advise you on the suitability of an investment to your personal circumstances. Nothing written on the site should be considered personal advice, nor do Holden & Partners accept liability for any inaccurate information on the site. If you are unsure about the suitability of an ethical and green investment please contact Holden & Partners or your financial adviser.

design/build by lexicon

© Worldwise Investor c/o Holden & Partners, The Piano Works, 117 Farringdon Road, London, EC1R 3BX 020 7812 1460 info@worldwiseinvestor.com
Worldwise Investor and Holden & Partners are trading names of Peter.R.T.Holden & Partners LLP regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (446291).